With the news that Congressman Anthony Weiner was going to seek treatment for his sexual addiction, Albert Mohler, President of Southern Baptist Theological Seminary tweeted, “Dear Congressman Weiner: There is no effective ‘treatment’ for sin. Only atonement, found only in Jesus Christ.” Rabbi Shmuley Boteach, founder of This World: The Values Network took exception to Mohler’s comments claiming that Mohler was trying to proselytize the congressman. Rabbi Shmuley responded to Mohler’s comments in an article in The Jewish Journal titled, “An Evangelical Attempts to Proselytize Anthony Weiner.”
In his response, Rabbi Shmuley made three statements that demonstrate just how different evangelical Christianity and Judaism really are. These statements are based on incorrect assumptions that Rabbi Shmuley makes about evangelical Christianity. He assumes that we believe that “salvation through Jesus Christ grants immunity to sexual sin” and that Christianity will prevent sin. No one with a correct understanding of evangelical Christianity would make these claims as they run contrary to Scripture, Old and New Testaments. Our faith does not prevent sin but it does provide a way out. “No temptation has overtaken you that is not common to man. God is faithful, and He will also provide the way of escape, that you may be able to endure it.” (1 Cor 10:13, ESV) Here, God supplies that which is necessary to overcome sin and temptation to those who have placed their faith in Him.
Rabbi Shmuley says, “Redemption comes about not through anything we believe but how we behave.” In this statement he makes redemption a matter of self-determination. We can will ourselves to be obedient enough to be redeemed. However, Genesis 15:6 concerning Abraham, the father of Judaism, “And he (Abraham) believed in the Lord, and He accounted it to him for righteousness” (NKJV, emphasis mine). To his credit, Rabbi Shmuley rightly says, “It is not faith that guarantees our morality but rather an ironclad commitment to righteous action, be we atheists or theist.” I believe this is true, but while faith does not guarantee our morality, neither does our morality guarantee the kingdom.
Secondly, Rabbi Shmuley says, “Redemption is never a function of belief and always a function of deed.” To support his view, he quotes Jesus in Matt 7:16, “You will know them by their fruits.” The Rabbi makes an excellent point and most evangelical Christians that I know will readily admit that there is a tension and a struggle between faith and obedience. The Rabbi in his statement though creates a rather extreme false choice that distinguishes between two biblically inseparable concepts, faith and works. In order for his statement to be aligned with Scripture (Old and New Testaments), it should read, “Redemption is always a function of belief that results in deeds.” James and the writer of Hebrews affirm the emphasis of obedience that comes from faith, but this obedience is empowered by God, not our will.
Thirdly, Rabbi Shmuley says, “Atonement comes not from belief in Jesus Christ but from getting on your knees in front of the wife whose heart you broke, begging her forgiveness, and placing yourself in an environment of change that will help sustain your new moral commitment.” Anthony Weiner should absolutely do these things and in them he and his wife may experience reconciliation. But to ascribe atonement to this act of self-vindication is to limit the concept of atonement to earthly relationships. Rabbi Shmuley grossly misses the point of the atoning sacrifice when he says, “Judaism is emphatic that when it comes to sins that pertain to human relationships, not even G-d can forgive. The injured party must be approached directly.”
The statements made by Rabbi Shmuley stem from the same type of moralistic deism that trapped the Pharisees of Jesus’ day into thinking that self-determination, self-righteousness, and self-vindication was enough to gain entrance to the kingdom. Nicodemus even struggled with the spiritual side to Jesus’ teaching. Rabbi Shmuley makes a similar mistake in limiting concepts such as redemption and atonement to the physical realm and physical relationships. However, he goes one step further. While the Pharisees of Jesus’ day misunderstood faith, Rabbi Shmuley seems to completely dismiss faith as irrelevant. The Bible is very clear when through the writer of Hebrews the Holy Spirit reminds us that, “without faith it is impossible to please [God],” (Heb 11:6, NKJV).
No comments:
Post a Comment